KiwiSaver has become a popular long-term savings vehicle in New Zealand, helping individuals save for their retirement and other significant life goals. However, with a plethora of KiwiSaver funds available in the market, each with its own investment strategy, risk profile, and fee structure, choosing the right one can be a daunting task. This article aims to provide a comprehensive guide to help investors make an informed decision when selecting a KiwiSaver fund.
Understanding KiwiSaver Funds
Types of KiwiSaver Funds
Growth Funds
Growth funds typically have a higher allocation to equities, both domestic and international. They are designed for investors with a long investment horizon and a higher risk tolerance. For example, a growth fund might have 80% or more of its assets in stocks. The rationale behind this is that over the long term, equities have the potential to provide higher returns compared to other asset classes. However, they are also more volatile. In a bull market, growth funds can experience significant capital appreciation. For instance, during periods of strong economic growth and rising stock markets, a growth fund may return 10% or more annually. But in a bear market or economic downturn, the value of the fund can decline substantially, sometimes by 20% or more.
Balanced Funds
Balanced funds maintain a mix of asset classes, usually a combination of equities, fixed-income securities (such as bonds), and sometimes a small allocation to cash or other assets. The typical asset allocation might be around 60% equities and 40% fixed income. This diversification helps to moderate the overall risk of the fund. They are suitable for investors with a moderate risk tolerance and a medium to long investment horizon. The returns of balanced funds are generally less volatile than growth funds. In a normal market environment, they might achieve annual returns in the range of 5% – 8%. During market downturns, the fixed-income component can act as a buffer, reducing the extent of losses compared to a pure growth fund.
Conservative Funds
Conservative funds have a higher proportion of fixed-income assets and a relatively small allocation to equities. They are geared towards investors who are risk-averse or nearing their retirement and have a shorter investment horizon. For example, a conservative fund could have 80% in bonds and other fixed-income securities and only 20% in equities. The returns of conservative funds are relatively stable but lower compared to growth and balanced funds. In a typical year, they may return around 3% – 5%. The primary objective is to preserve capital while generating a modest return.
Investment Objectives and Risk Profiles
Long-Term Growth vs. Capital Preservation
Investors with a long time until retirement, such as those in their 20s or 30s, may prioritize long-term growth. They can afford to take on more risk as they have time to ride out market fluctuations. For them, growth funds might be a suitable option. On the other hand, investors who are close to retirement, say in their 60s, may be more concerned about preserving the capital they have accumulated. In this case, a conservative fund would be more appropriate. For example, a 25-year-old investor who plans to retire at 65 has 40 years to invest. Even if they experience a significant market downturn in the early years, there is still ample time for the market to recover and for their investment to grow. In contrast, a 62-year-old investor may not have the luxury of waiting for a market recovery and needs to ensure their savings are relatively secure.
Risk Tolerance
Risk tolerance is a crucial factor in choosing a KiwiSaver fund. Some investors are comfortable with the ups and downs of the market and can tolerate a significant decline in the value of their investment in the short term. These investors may opt for growth funds. However, others may become anxious or stressed at the slightest market volatility. Such risk-averse investors should consider conservative funds. For instance, an investor who checks their KiwiSaver balance frequently and panics when they see a small drop in value is likely to have a low risk tolerance and would be better off with a more stable investment option.
Considerations for Selecting a KiwiSaver Fund
Fees and Charges
Management Fees
Management fees are charged by the fund provider for managing the fund’s assets. These fees can vary significantly among different funds. For example, some growth funds may have management fees of 1.5% or more, while some conservative funds may have fees as low as 0.5%. Over the long term, even a small difference in management fees can have a substantial impact on the overall return of the investment. For an investment of $100,000, a 1% difference in management fees over 20 years can result in a difference of tens of thousands of dollars in the final value of the investment.
Transaction Costs
Transaction costs are incurred when the fund buys and sells assets within the portfolio. These costs are not always transparent to the investor. High-turnover funds, which frequently buy and sell securities, may have higher transaction costs. For example, a fund that actively trades stocks may have to pay brokerage fees, stamp duties, and other costs associated with trading. These costs can eat into the returns of the fund. In contrast, a passively managed index fund, which aims to replicate the performance of a market index, generally has lower transaction costs as it has less frequent trading.
Past Performance
Importance of Long-Term Performance
While past performance is not a guarantee of future results, it can provide some insights into how a fund has managed different market conditions. Looking at the long-term performance of a KiwiSaver fund, say over a 5 – 10 year period, can give an indication of its consistency and ability to generate returns. For example, a fund that has consistently outperformed its peers and the market benchmark over a decade may have a competent investment team and a sound investment strategy. However, it is essential to understand the factors that contributed to the past performance. A fund that achieved high returns in a particular period may have been taking on excessive risk or may have benefited from a specific market trend that may not continue in the future.
Benchmark Comparison
Comparing a fund’s performance against an appropriate benchmark is crucial. For a growth fund with a significant international equity exposure, a relevant benchmark could be a global equity index. If a fund consistently underperforms its benchmark, it may indicate that the fund’s investment strategy or management is not effective. For example, if a growth fund has an annual return of 6% while its benchmark index has a return of 8% over the same period, it may be a cause for concern. However, it is also important to consider the fund’s risk-adjusted performance. A fund may have a lower return than the benchmark but may have achieved it with lower volatility, which could still make it an attractive option for some investors.
Fund Provider Reputation and Stability
Reputation in the Market
The reputation of the fund provider is an important consideration. A well-established and respected fund provider is more likely to have a reliable investment process, experienced fund managers, and good corporate governance. For example, some large financial institutions with a long history in the market have a reputation for providing quality investment services. They may have a team of research analysts who conduct in-depth research on the companies and assets in which the fund invests. Additionally, a provider with a good reputation is more likely to handle client inquiries and complaints effectively.
Financial Stability
The financial stability of the fund provider is also crucial. Investors want to ensure that the provider will be able to manage the fund’s assets and meet its obligations even in difficult market conditions. A financially stable provider is less likely to face liquidity issues or be forced to sell assets at unfavorable prices. For instance, during a financial crisis, a well-capitalized fund provider can continue to operate and manage the fund’s investments without significant disruptions, providing peace of mind to the investors.
The Role of Investor Circumstances
Age and Investment Horizon
Younger Investors
Younger investors, typically those under 40, have a long investment horizon. They can afford to take more risks and should consider a higher allocation to growth funds. For example, a 30-year-old investor can allocate 80% of their KiwiSaver funds to a growth fund and 20% to a balanced fund. This allows them to benefit from the potential for high returns from equities over the long term. Even if the market experiences a significant downturn, they have time to recover and potentially gain from the subsequent market upswing.
Middle-Aged Investors
Middle-aged investors, say between 40 and 60, may want to start gradually reducing their exposure to growth funds and increasing their allocation to balanced funds. For a 50-year-old investor, a 50 – 50 split between a balanced fund and a growth fund could be appropriate. This helps to balance the need for continued growth with the need to manage risk as they approach retirement.
Older Investors
Older investors, especially those over 60 and nearing retirement, should focus on capital preservation. A conservative fund or a combination of a conservative and a balanced fund would be more suitable. For example, an investor who is 65 and retired may allocate 80% to a conservative fund and 20% to a balanced fund to ensure a stable income stream while still having some exposure to potential growth.
Income and Savings Goals
Low-Income Earners
Low-income earners may have limited discretionary income to contribute to their KiwiSaver. They may want to focus on funds with lower fees to maximize the growth of their contributions. Additionally, if they have a shorter investment horizon or a more immediate need for the funds, such as for a first home purchase, a more conservative fund might be appropriate. For example, a young person on a minimum wage who is saving for a house deposit may choose a conservative KiwiSaver fund to ensure the safety of their savings.
High-Income Earners
High-income earners may have a higher capacity to take risks and can afford to contribute more to their KiwiSaver. They may consider a growth fund or a combination of growth and balanced funds. They may also be more interested in funds that offer additional features such as ethical investing options or access to exclusive investment opportunities. For instance, a high-income earner who is passionate about environmental sustainability may choose a growth fund that focuses on investing in companies with strong environmental, social, and governance (ESG) practices.
Additional Features and Considerations
Ethical and Socially Responsible Investing
ESG Criteria
Some KiwiSaver funds follow ethical and socially responsible investing principles, incorporating Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) criteria into their investment decisions. These funds may avoid investing in companies involved in activities such as tobacco production, weapons manufacturing, or those with a poor environmental record. For example, an ESG-focused fund may not invest in coal mining companies due to their significant environmental impact. For investors who have strong ethical beliefs and want their investments to align with their values, these funds can be an attractive option.
Impact Investing
Impact investing goes a step further than ESG investing. It aims to not only avoid harmful companies but also actively invest in companies and projects that have a positive social or environmental impact. For instance, a KiwiSaver fund may invest in renewable energy projects, affordable housing initiatives, or companies that promote gender equality in the workplace. Impact investing allows investors to contribute to positive change while also potentially achieving financial returns.
Insurance and Other Benefits
Life and Disability Insurance
Some KiwiSaver funds offer life and disability insurance as part of the package. The level of insurance coverage can vary among funds. For example, a fund may provide life insurance equal to a certain multiple of the member’s account balance. This can be a valuable benefit, especially for those who may not have other forms of insurance. However, it is important to understand the terms and conditions of the insurance, such as the exclusions and the cost. In some cases, the cost of the insurance may be factored into the fund’s fees.
Contribution Matching
Some employers or the government may offer contribution matching for KiwiSaver funds. This means that for every dollar an investor contributes, the employer or the government will contribute a certain amount, up to a limit. For example, an employer may match 50% of an employee’s contribution up to 3% of their salary. Investors should consider funds that are eligible for such contribution matching as it can significantly boost their savings.
Conclusion
Choosing the right KiwiSaver fund is a complex decision that requires careful consideration of multiple factors. Investors need to assess their own investment objectives, risk tolerance, age, income, and savings goals. They should also evaluate the fees and charges, past performance, and reputation of the fund provider. Additionally, features such as ethical investing options, insurance, and contribution matching can also play a role in the decision-making process. By taking the time to understand these aspects and conducting thorough research, investors can select a KiwiSaver fund that is best suited to their individual circumstances and help them achieve their long-term financial goals. It is also advisable for investors to review their KiwiSaver fund selection periodically, especially when there are significant changes in their personal or financial situation, or in the market environment.
Related topics:
What Is the Oldest Mutual Fund Still Active
What Are the 8 Best Vanguard Etfs
